Each language covers five different levels, except for mandarin, which covers three. Overview the fluenz software greatly helps with speaking, listening, reading, and writing. Fluenz believes adults learn best when they can relate the grammar and syntax of a foreign language to the structure of the tongue they already know, their advertising copy states. In this respect, fluenz mandarin is infinitely better than both rosetta stone and berlitz and roughly on par with rocket chinese which has its own effective tonal lessons.
Every lesson comes with a pdf transcription and translation. In the question what are the best sites for learning foreign languages. Fluenz is a digital language learning platform developed by fluenz inc. Both companies score similarly on cost, educational model, and additional features. It distinguishes itself from other notable language apps, particularly rosetta stone, by using english instruction and teaching grammar. When i first started using fluenz mandarin, i was surprised to discover that my guide through the lessons was a cute young white nonnative speaker. The strength of the fluenz mandarin program partly depends on what your actual goals are for learning the language. Dec 01, 2018 fluenz can be still considered as a new language learning program therefore it is available for fewer foreign languages. The pros and cons of 7 leading online language courses fluentu. Note that with the mandarin program, you wont learn to read or write chinese, as it uses. On your phone, laptop, or tablet, well take you to fluency with hundreds of videotutorials with tens of thousands of workouts. I recommend reading this article, then checking out why fluenz french is better than rosetta stone. Rosetta stone chinese is a good option for new leaners who want to get comfortable in the basics of the mandarin language.
Rosetta stone is the bestknown company in foreign language learning. I am as of this writing on lesson 57 out of 75 lessons. If youre having trouble remembering where a certain word or phrase is located, then consulting the course contents is an easy way to find it. This document is provided for informational purposes only and rosetta stone ltd. User experience the interface is easy to use and works fine on mac osx mountain lion. Rosetta stone believes in fully immersing the student in the language, without using any english to explain phrases.
I was further impressed by fluenz when i was contacted by the company in october 2009 and sent an unsolicited, full upgrade for v2 of mandarin, spanish. Pimsleur seems to be a less intuitive way to learn, and more structured like a classroom, so it helped with mandarin since i really didnt understand measure words or lack of verb tense. Have used other language learning programs including rosetta stone, which i enjoyed and do not disparage but for myself and the way i learn a foreign language i prefer the fluenz methodology. This makes for a more helpful indepth approach to language learning. French, german, italian, mandarin, spanish spain and portuguese. Rosetta stone scores better than rocket languages across. With fluenz you are learning from a person who you can clearly see mouth the words.
I used pimsleur until i mastered the entire program from front to back, yet i was completely lost when i went to china. Rosetta stone language software has a higher overall rating than rocket languages language software. So maybe you are wondering how well it has worked for others and if it would work well for you. Fluenz language learning software learning choices. Rosetta stone is probably the most wellknown language learning software. While rosetta stone, busu, babbel teach spanish in the same way to chinese and american learners, the language you speak should determine the path when learning a new one. Thats because a big portion of the program teaches you separate words without. I could understand things here and there, but by and large i was totally lost. If you set it to manual, you have to advance by clicking on the button for the next. The layout of fluenz is more engaging, the material is less repetitive, and its packed with content. Read this exciting story from pc magazine february 2018. Spanish latin america, spanish spain, french, italian, german, english american, english british, arabic, chinese mandarin, dari, dutch. Ive tried both rosetta stone and fluenz for mandarin, and by far, fluenz offers the better path for retention of vocabulary and functional words you are going to use.
You will learn spanish faster with fluenz because weve designed it based on the needs of english speakers. I love learning languages yet despite studying three languages throughout elementary, grade school and coll. Rosetta stone incorporates practicing mandarin pronunciations into every lesson with a patented speech recognition engine called truaccent. Fluenz is the comprehensive languagelearning solution that brings it all together from beginning to end. Fluenz looks at the issues commonly encountered, and tailors its lessons accordingly. Writing chinese is either drawing the character, or typing the pinyin and selecting. Rosetta stone remains the best premium software for building a foundation in. Pimsleur does have reading lessons but its not the main focus. The real problem i have with rosetta stone is just how tedious and boring it is. While the chinese courses share many of the common weaknesses of rosetta stone courses, they are still an effective way to learn basic grammar and vocabulary, as well work on pronunciation. I have tried the rosetta stone courseware in other languages so i wanted to try a different method for mandarin.
While youtube videos and free lingo apps are helpful, the only way to really learn a language is to understand its workings from end to end, and to engage in targeted practice designed to unleash fluency. Babbel is ranked 16th while rosetta stone is ranked 17th. Truaccent encourages language learners to repeat words or phrases, comparing your accent to that of native chinese speakers and providing instantaneous feedback for improvement. Course contents for rosetta stone language training rosetta. Or maybe youd like to brush up on that italian or german you studied years ago. All information in this document is subject to change without notice. Firstly, pimsleur teaches you through listening and repeating. Theres a lot of small issues that are very bothersome. Personal expereince using rosetta stone vs pimsleur typically i post about security topics on this blog however i want to share my experience trying to learn mandarin. One of the things that amazes the most when i travel is the ease with which the rest of the world is multilingual while americans can get away with relying on just one common tongue. Lessons include substantial video tutorials, interactive exercises and practices, audio with native speakers and great visuals to keep you excited the fluenz spanish system.
Fluenz ranks among the best languagelearning software. The product range consists of programs to learn spanish as spoken in latin america, spanish as spoken in spain, french, italian, mandarin, german, and portuguese. One thing that will strike you when using rosetta stone is the blandness of its interface. Rosetta stone spanish, that really depends on your needs and goals. You get 30 sessions in each level, each focusing on a. I spent the last 12 years trying both rosetta stone and later pimsleur dedicating at least an hour a day towards learning. Fluenz is a classroom language course compressed onto cd and dvd and, whereas rosetta claims to immerse you in mandarin without explanation or instruction, fluenz does the opposite. Is rosetta stone for mandarin a good learning tool. Rosetta stone and fluenz are often compared to each other but they. The hosts discuss a dialogue and then explain important vocabulary, grammar, and cultural information.
Unlike rosetta stone, fluenz offers english explanations for all of the material it covers. Rosetta stone on the other hand, teaches through pictures, audio, and writing. Jul 24, 2017 rosetta stone chinese is a good option for new leaners who want to get comfortable in the basics of the mandarin language. Thats why rosetta stone incorporates the opportunity to speak and get feedback on your mandarin pronunciation from the very first lesson. Is rosetta stone for mandarin chinese a good learning tool. However, fluenz french makes it as simple and easy as possible with its range of course materials. Videos of real instructors shepherd you through the course, which also includes all the interactive exercises one expects to find in. Its excellent for beginners, and optional online classes give it an edge over other programs. Every moment of learning has been carefully calibrated to help you master the language. Learn mandarin chinese learn chinese while you sleep 230 basic phrases duration. Be fluent in mandarin onscreen tutor sonia gil, a recent cornell graduate, and alumni from harvard and the university of chicago created fluenz mandarin to be the kind of application they had always wanted when learning languages.
Has anyone used rosetta stone, fluenz or tellmemore. This software was designed by a small team with a clear mission. The interactive content can be downloadable or accessed online on computers and mobile devices. I travel to taiwan and mainland china a couple of times a year now, and now ill be able to explore without fear of being hopelessly lost. Oct 14, 2015 ive worked with both fluenz and rosetta stone version 3. I have rosetta stone mandarin and used it for several weeks before a business trip to china. Fluenz is a bit more expensive than rosetta stone, but you get what you pay for.
Comprehensive and thorough, not a quick overnight fix. No matter if its a good gym, a reliable server for my website or a language course. A forbes journalist took the time to come to mexico to immerse herself for a full week in the fluenz spanish experience. Jan 04, 2009 ive tried both rosetta stone and fluenz for mandarin, and by far, fluenz offers the better path for retention of vocabulary and functional words you are going to use. Got there and realized that while i knew how to say things like car, cat and horse, i couldnt put a basic sentence together. Ive worked with both fluenz and rosetta stone version 3. Lets learn mandarin together rosetta stone 1 youtube. Fluenz recreates aspects of classroom learning in its foreign language instruction. Fluenz doesnt make any wildly impossible claims like the ones made by pimsleur approach that you can learn a language in ten days, and there are no claims like the ones rosetta stone makes that you will learn effortlessly like a child. Ive never tried fluenz, but i have used rosetta stone, and it is not worth the price.
As we mentioned before, mandarin is a stressedtime tonal language, so practicing pronunciation until you feel confident is an essential first step in speaking chinese. Fluenz believes adults learn best when they can relate the grammar and syntax of a foreign language to the structure of the tongue they already know. The only interactive language program offering an immersive environment that recreates the best elements of great oneonone tutoring. It teaches via dynamic immersion which means they try to teach you the language similar to the way you learned your native language as a child. The biggest negative is that rosetta stone is extremely expensive. You can use it on a great range of devices, all of which synchronize so you never miss a class. Many online language courses are free or very cheap. Its one of the best, and most often recommended resources for studying chinese. Fluenz mandarin is an interactive multimedia product, with audio, writing, reading, and speaking instruction. Fluenz french is a great product for anyone prepared to put the time and effort in to learn the language properly.
The article will compare rosetta stone levels 15 against fluenz french levels 15 and explain to you why one language program is definitively better than the other. Apr 10, 2019 rosetta stone remains the best premium software for building a foundation in a foreign language. Visual mandarin learners tend to prefer fluenz program for studying mandarin. It explains using english grammar comparison and it introduces the chinese mandarin four tone system essential for being understood in mandarin speaking cities. At the moment it is possible to get this program for studying mandarin, french, spanish, german and few other foreign languages. Weve invested millions of dollars to find just the right sequence, timing, and explanation you will need. Learn mandarin chinese learn chinese while you sleep 230 basic phrases. Fluenz, while short, uses leveraged learning and explains the meaning and.
Stone to be the best hands down for languages that have similar structure to english, but when i tried to use it for mandarin, i was horribly lost. At rosetta stone they believe that the most natural way to study a foreign. This is a bit disappointing because it means youll struggle to work out whether or not their system suits you, without having to pay for the courses. There are no shortcuts here and no pretence that learning a language is an easy task. Rosetta stone remains the best premium software for building a foundation in a foreign language. The main difference is that they claim that explanations are very important. So to answer the question which is better fluenz spanish vs. Mcgrawhill makes some damn good language books at least for spanish, but their best is the stepbystep series. Personal expereince using rosetta stone vs pimsleur the. The lessons are in the form of a podcast, typically from 1020 minutes long. When comparing babbel vs rosetta stone, the slant community recommends babbel for most people.
105 1404 366 456 2 406 1334 734 141 1066 689 852 304 89 1476 907 1004 1352 1387 206 1135 982 789 337 298 1303 1446 1414 724